Expert Eye Makeup Tips & Dark Under-Eye Circle Remedies

Celebrity makeup artist Christina Flach demonstrates expert eye makeup tips and dark under-eye circle remedies with a before and after transformation.

As a makeup artist, I’ve spent decades helping women look refreshed, confident, and camera-ready for shoots. While everyone wants brighter eyes and longer lashes, one of the biggest beauty mistakes I see has nothing to do with makeup application—it’s how makeup is removed at the end of the day.
The skin around your eyes is incredibly delicate. Tugging, rubbing, or sleeping in makeup can lead to irritation, puffiness, and can make dark under-eye circles appear even more noticeable. The good news? A few simple habits can make a big difference.

Here are my favorite tips for creating beautiful eye makeup while keeping the eye area healthy and youthful.

Prep the Eye Area
Hydrated skin is the foundation of beautiful makeup. Apply a lightweight eye cream and allow it to absorb before concealer or shadow. If you have dry skin, use a heavier moisturizer before the eye cream. I love to layer the creams/moisturizer because it makes the concealer look more natural.

Prime for Success
An eye primer helps shadow stay in place, prevents creasing, and creates a smoother, more polished finish. Think of it as the foundation beneath your eye makeup—it helps everything applied afterward perform better and last longer.
One of the biggest challenges with eye makeup is that the eyelids naturally produce oil throughout the day. Without a primer, eyeshadow can fade, crease, or settle into fine lines. A good primer creates a smooth canvas and helps colors appear more vibrant and true to their original shade.
In some cases, I will use a small amount of concealer on the eyelid instead of a traditional eye primer. This is especially helpful if you have redness, visible veins, discoloration, or uneven pigmentation on the lid. Concealer instantly brightens and neutralizes the area, creating a clean, even base for eyeshadow application.
If you choose to use concealer, apply a very thin layer and blend it well. The goal is to create a smooth surface, not add heaviness. Once blended, you can apply your shadows directly on top for a brighter, more polished look.
One of my favorite tricks is using a touch of concealer from the lash line all the way up to the brow bone. It instantly refreshes the eye area and creates the appearance of brighter, more awake eyes before you’ve even applied a single shadow.
Great eye makeup doesn’t start with eyeshadow—it starts with creating the perfect canvas underneath it.

 Choose a Hydrating Concealer and Skip the Powder

One of the biggest mistakes I see women make is using a matte, drying concealer under the eyes and then setting it with powder. The under-eye area is naturally thin and delicate, and powder can emphasize fine lines, texture, and wrinkles.
Instead, choose a creamy, hydrating concealer that melts into the skin and reflects light. Under-eye concealer is one of the most powerful products in your makeup bag—it can brighten tired eyes, camouflage dark circles, soften discoloration, and instantly make you look more rested and refreshed. I often  use a thin layer of concealer on the lid, it brightens and evens out the discoloration we all have there.  After completing your eye makeup, add a final thin layer of concealer if needed to brighten and perfect the under-eye area.

Choose Neutral Tones That Enhance Your Natural Beauty

While bold colors can be beautiful for fashion, editorial work, and special occasions, I believe neutral tones are the most flattering choice for everyday wear. The goal isn’t to have people notice your eyeshadow—it’s to have them notice your eyes.
Start with a light, creamy neutral shade across the entire lid to create a bright, polished base. Then add soft taupes, warm browns, or subtle bronzes to create definition and dimension. These shades work beautifully on virtually every eye color and skin tone.
For eyeliner, don’t be afraid to use eyeshadow instead of a traditional pencil or liquid liner. Applying a liner first and then layering a coordinating shadow on top improves longevity, softens the look, and allows you to blend away any imperfections. This technique creates definition while still looking natural and effortless.
The best eye makeup doesn’t transform you into someone else—it helps you look like the most beautiful version of yourself.

Keep Your Brushes Clean for Better Blending and Truer Color
A great eyeshadow habit is dedicating one brush to your light lid color and avoiding darker shades with it. This prevents color contamination and keeps light shadows looking fresh and bright instead of muddy. Using separate brushes for different shades also helps maintain true color payoff and creates a cleaner, more polished finish.
Regular brush maintenance is equally important. Clean your brushes at least once a week to remove product buildup, oils, and bacteria. Wash them with a gentle shampoo  or use a makeup wipe when needed. Then, towel dry and let them air dry completely before use. Treat your brushes like your hair and they will last longer. 
Clean brushes not only help your makeup look better, but they also make blending easier and keep your colors looking fresh and true every time you apply them.

Fill in Your Brows to Frame the Face
If the eyes are the focal point of the face, the brows are the frame. Well-groomed brows help define the eyes, create balance, and instantly make your entire makeup look  more polished and intentional.
One of the most common mistakes I see is overlooking the brows altogether. Sparse or uneven brows can make the eyes appear less defined, while properly shaped brows create structure and draw attention exactly where you want it—toward the eyes.
You don’t need heavily drawn or overly dramatic brows. In fact, I prefer a softer, more natural approach. Use a brow pencil, brow powder, or a combination of both to fill in sparse areas with light, hair-like strokes. The goal is to enhance your natural shape, not create a completely new one.

I often use a shadow to softly build fullness and then add a few strategic pencil strokes to mimic natural hairs where additional definition is needed. This combination creates brows that look full, natural, and believable.
As we age, brows can become thinner and lighter. Taking a few moments to fill them in can create a more youthful appearance and help lift the entire face.
Beautiful brows don’t need to be the star of the show. Their job is to frame the eyes, balance the face, and make everything else look even better.
One of the quickest ways to look more polished isn’t adding more makeup—it’s finishing your brows.

Curl Your Lashes- But Don't Over Do It

A lash curler can be one of the most transformative tools in your makeup bag. It instantly opens the eyes, makes lashes appear longer, and helps you look more awake and refreshed. It’s one of my favorite tricks for clients who want a subtle lift without looking overly made up.
That said, I don’t recommend using a lash curler every day. Like the hair on your head, lashes can weaken from repeated mechanical stress. Frequent pressure, especially when combined with waterproof mascara or improper use, may contribute to breakage over time.
If you choose to curl your lashes, always do so before applying mascara and use a gentle touch rather than squeezing aggressively. Make sure the curler’s pad is clean and in good condition, as worn-out pads can damage delicate lashes.
For special occasions, photoshoots, events, or days when you want a little extra polish, a lash curler can make a remarkable difference. But on everyday makeup days, allowing your natural lashes a break can help keep them healthy, strong, and full.
Beautiful lashes aren’t just about how they look today—it’s about protecting them so they continue to look their best for years to come.

  Define the Eyes Without Making Them Look Smaller

One of the most common mistakes I see is applying a thick, heavy line of eyeliner across the upper lid. While many people think more liner creates more drama, it often has the opposite effect—it can make the eyes appear smaller, heavier, and more closed off.
Instead, I recommend a thin line close to the lash line or a subtle tightline technique that enhances the shape of the eye without overpowering it. A softer, thinner line creates definition while maintaining an open, bright appearance. The goal is for people to notice your eyes, not your eyeliner.
Another trick I swear by is keeping the center of the eyelid light. Light colors reflect light and create the illusion of larger, more youthful-looking eyes. I rarely place dark shadow in the middle of the lid because it can make the eye appear smaller and more recessed.
If you’d like to add a little more drama, focus a slightly deeper shadow in the crease rather than on the lid itself. This creates dimension and contour while keeping the eye looking open and lifted.
For women with smaller eyes, this technique is especially important. Keep the lid bright, light, and reflective, and use darker shades sparingly in the crease and outer corners. The contrast creates depth without sacrificing openness.
When it comes to eye makeup, remember that light brings features forward while dark colors push them back. If your goal is bigger, brighter-looking eyes, keep the lid light and let strategic definition do the work.

 Apply Mascara Strategically for Bigger, Brighter Eyes

Mascara is one of the quickest ways to wake up the face and make the eyes appear larger, brighter, and more youthful. The key is applying it strategically rather than simply piling it on.
Start by placing the mascara wand at the roots of the lashes and gently wiggling it back and forth before pulling upward. This builds fullness at the lash line, where it creates the greatest impact, while keeping the lashes separated and natural-looking.
One of my favorite tricks is to concentrate extra mascara on the outer corner lashes. Extending the lashes outward creates a subtle lifting effect that helps elongate the eyes and gives them a more open, youthful appearance.
I also encourage women to think beyond basic black mascara. If you have fair skin, blonde hair, red hair, light eyes, or softer coloring, a rich brown mascara can be incredibly flattering. Brown mascara defines the lashes beautifully while looking softer and more natural than black. Often, people notice your eyes rather than your makeup.
Another important beauty habit is replacing your mascara every three months. Mascara can harbor bacteria over time, and older formulas become dry, flaky, and less effective. Fresh mascara not only performs better but is healthier for your eyes.
As for waterproof mascara, I reserve it for special occasions such as weddings, beach vacations, pool days, humid climates, or emotional events where tears are likely. Waterproof formulas are much more difficult to remove and often require additional rubbing around the delicate eye area. Over time, this can contribute to lash breakage and unnecessary stress on both the lashes and the skin surrounding the eyes.
For everyday wear, I strongly prefer traditional mascara that removes easily and allows you to cleanse the eye area gently. Healthy lashes are always more beautiful than damaged ones.
The goal isn’t to have the thickest lashes in the room—it’s to create eyes that look bright, lifted, healthy, and naturally beautiful.

Brighten the Inner Corners for an Instant Eye Lift

If I could give every woman one quick eye makeup trick, it would be this: brighten the inner corners of your eyes.
The inner corner is where shadows naturally occur, especially if you’re tired, dealing with allergies, or have naturally deeper-set eyes. Adding a touch of light in this area instantly wakes up the face and creates the illusion of brighter, more open eyes.
For daytime, I love using a soft matte or satin shade in an ivory, cream, or “eggnog” tone that complements your skin tone. These lighter shades reflect light beautifully without looking overly made up and help create a fresh, well-rested appearance.
For evening or special occasions, you can elevate the look with a subtle shimmer or pearl finish. The reflective particles catch the light and create a gorgeous sparkle that makes the eyes appear larger and more luminous.
One reason this technique works so well is that light naturally draws attention forward. By brightening the inner corners, you bring focus to the eyes while softening the appearance of darkness and shadow around them.
I also like to carry a touch of that same light shade just beneath the highest point of the brow bone. Used sparingly, it creates a subtle lift and helps tie the entire eye look together.
The key is restraint. You don’t want a stripe of obvious shimmer. The goal is for people to think you look rested, bright, and radiant—not to notice exactly why.
It’s a small detail, but sometimes the smallest details make the biggest difference.

Skip Heavy Lower Liner and Keep the Eyes Open

A common mistake is applying a dark, heavy line across the entire lower lash line. While it may seem like it would make the eyes stand out, it often does the opposite. Heavy lower liner can emphasize under-eye shadows, draw attention to dark circles, and make the eyes appear smaller and more tired.
Instead, use a softer approach. A thin line close to the lower lash line or a subtle sweep of eyeshadow adds definition without overwhelming the eye. Soft brown, taupe, or neutral shades often look more natural and forgiving than harsh black liner.
One of my favorite techniques is pressing a small amount of shadow into the lower lash line and gently blending it. This creates soft definition while maintaining an open, youthful appearance.
If your goal is bigger, brighter-looking eyes, keep the lower lash line light and soft. Makeup should enhance your features, not compete with them. A subtle touch of shadow can beautifully accentuate the eyes while keeping them the focal point.
The most flattering eye makeup doesn’t make the eyes look heavily lined—it makes them look naturally larger, brighter, and more awake.

Never Rub Your Eyes

The skin around your eyes is the thinnest and most delicate skin on your entire body. It’s also one of the first places to show signs of aging, which is why treating it gently is so important.
Whether you’re removing makeup, dealing with allergies, or simply feeling tired, avoid rubbing or pulling at the eye area. Repeated friction can contribute to irritation, puffiness, broken capillaries, inflammation, and over time may make fine lines and wrinkles appear more noticeable.
When removing eye makeup, patience is your best friend. Saturate a cotton pad with a gentle eye makeup remover and hold it against the eye for several seconds. This allows the product to break down mascara, eyeliner, and shadow before you wipe. The less rubbing required, the better.
I am especially cautious about waterproof mascara. While it has its place for weddings, beach days, and special occasions, it often requires more effort to remove, which can lead to unnecessary pulling on both the lashes and the delicate skin around the eyes.
If you suffer from allergies or itchy eyes, try using a cool compress instead of rubbing. Not only will it feel soothing, but it can also help reduce puffiness and inflammation.
One of the best beauty habits you can develop is treating the eye area with the same care you would give a delicate piece of silk. The gentler you are today, the healthier and more youthful the eye area is likely to look years from now.
Beautiful eyes aren’t just created with makeup—they’re protected by the habits you practice every day.

Always Remove Makeup Before Bed

If there is one beauty rule I wish every woman would follow, it’s this: always remove your makeup before bed. 
Throughout the day, makeup, sunscreen, oil, dirt, and pollutants build up on the skin. Leaving them on overnight can lead to clogged pores, irritation, and dullness.
The good news is that removing your makeup doesn’t have to be complicated. I like using a natural oil such as coconut or apricot oil to dissolve makeup, especially around the eyes, then following with a gentle cleanser and your nighttime skincare products.
If you’re wearing heavier makeup, a makeup wipe can be a helpful first step, but it should be followed by a proper cleanse whenever possible.
And let’s be honest—there are nights when you’re exhausted. If you can’t manage your full routine, at least use a warm washcloth and a gentle cleanser or face cream to remove the day’s makeup before bed.
Perfection isn’t the goal—consistency is.
Your skin does much of its repair work while you sleep, so starting with a clean canvas helps your products work more effectively and keeps your complexion looking healthier over time.
Taking five minutes to remove your makeup may not feel important in the moment, but your future skin will thank you.
The best beauty routine isn’t the most expensive one—it’s the one you actually do every day.

 The Makeup Removal Mistake That Can Make Under-Eye Circles Look Worse

Many women try to conceal dark circles while unknowingly making them appear worse during their nightly makeup removal routine.
The biggest mistake is rubbing and tugging at the delicate skin around the eyes. Whether removing waterproof mascara, eyeliner, or long-wear makeup, aggressive rubbing can cause irritation, inflammation, puffiness, and redness, making under-eye circles appear darker and more noticeable.
Another common issue is not removing eye makeup completely. Leftover mascara, eyeliner, and shadow can migrate overnight, creating darkness beneath the eyes and leaving you looking tired the next morning.
Instead of scrubbing, let your makeup remover do the work. Saturate a cotton pad with remover, coconut oil, or apricot oil and hold it gently over the eye for several seconds to break down makeup before wiping it away with minimal rubbing.

I also recommend avoiding waterproof mascara for everyday use. While useful for special occasions, it often requires more effort to remove and can lead to unnecessary pulling on the lashes and surrounding skin.
The skin around the eyes is extremely thin, so treat it gently and remove makeup thoroughly. Often, it’s not just the makeup you wear that affects how refreshed your eyes look—it’s how you remove it.

Beautiful eye makeup isn’t about following every trend. It’s about enhancing your natural features while taking care of the delicate skin around your eyes. A great eye look starts with healthy skin, the correct shades to enhance your eyes , and  a consistent nighttime routine.
Remember, the goal isn't for people to notice your makeup - it's for them to notice YOU!

— Christina Flach Celebrity Makeup Artist & Founder of Pretty Girl Makeup

Ready to book your makeup lesson with Christina? Book Now